Edge Cases: The Weird Situations AVs Have to Handle
A mattress falls off a truck. A construction worker waves you through cones. Learn what edge cases are and how AVs are designed to handle them safely.
December 5, 2024 · 3 min read
Most of driving is boring: straight roads, green lights, simple turns.
But every so often, something weird happens — a mattress falls off a truck, a temporary detour appears, or a person in a costume walks into the street.
AV engineers call these edge cases.
What is an edge case?
An edge case is a situation that:
- Doesn't happen very often
- Doesn't look exactly like anything in the training data
- Still must be handled safely
Examples include:
- A construction worker waving you around cones in a non-standard way
- A fire truck parked at an odd angle blocking multiple lanes
- A pedestrian on an electric scooter weaving between cars
- A lane completely closed with improvised signage
For humans, we rely on life experience: "This is unusual, I'll slow down and be careful." AVs need that behavior encoded in software.
How AVs prepare for edge cases
AV programs don't wait to stumble on every rare event in the real world. They use several tools:
Simulation
- Engineers can create thousands of weird situations virtually.
- They test how the system responds and refine behavior until it handles them well.
Scenario libraries
- Real incidents from the road (both common and rare) are recorded.
- These are turned into reusable test scenarios for future versions.
Conservative defaults
- When something doesn't match expectations, the system can choose safer behaviors: slow down, increase distance, or stop and wait.
What "handling safely" means
Handling an edge case safely doesn't always mean gliding through it smoothly on the first try. Sometimes it means:
- Slowing down earlier than a human would
- Stopping when it's not strictly necessary, then proceeding after re-evaluation
- Taking a longer, alternative route around a blocked road
From a rider's perspective, this can feel cautious or even slightly annoying. From a safety perspective, it's exactly what you want: better a cautious pause than a risky guess.
Why you hear about edge cases in the news
When an AV encounters something strange or makes an error in a rare situation, it often becomes a headline. That makes sense — it's new, and people are watching closely.
What you don't see as often are the thousands of times per day AVs:
- Correctly identify a construction zone
- Safely handle a double-parked truck
- Navigate around a stalled vehicle
Those are edge cases too; they just didn't turn into viral clips.
The long game: Making edge cases less "edge"
Over time, as AVs:
- Experience more real-world miles
- Face more unusual situations
- Improve their training data and simulation scenarios
…many edge cases become standard, well-handled scenarios.
The goal isn't to predict every bizarre event in advance. It's to build a system that:
- Recognizes when something is unusual
- Responds cautiously
- Learns from experience and gets better over time
Takeaway
Edge cases are not a reason to dismiss AVs. They're a reason to ask how a system is designed to recognize and respond to the unusual.
In that sense, AVs and humans share the same challenge: staying safe when something unexpected happens. AVs just approach it with lots of data, simulation, and conservative logic.